Caring is so “cliche”: the curse of youthful idealism

Recently, I met up with an old friend and we were swapping stories about our current career interests. Of course I started talking about my hopes of becoming a public interest attorney, and she responded by saying “Wow…that is so cliche!” She felt like this whole idea of wanting to “save the world” or “help people” sounded extremely cliche. (Note: saying you want to “save the world” is derogatory. Skeptics often use this statement in order to belittle those who actually want to make a difference).

I’ve heard the same thing in the past from admissions officers, blogs, friends, and family. If you write in your law school application that you want to use your law degree for good, that you’re going to law school in order to make this world a better place….well, let’s just say that you’re not looked upon very favorably, but are thought to be some idealistic, cliche young person who is stereotypically trying to BS his or her way into law school but has NO idea what the real world actually entails. I can just imagine admissions officers out there glancing skeptically at the essay of yet ANOTHER 21 year old who wants to “save the world” or “make the world a better place,” and rolling their eyes, knowing that this 21 year old in reality would most likely quickly switch over to corporate law once they actually get an offer.

The thing is, everyone expects young people to eventually “grow out” of this idealistic phase in our lives. The idea is that we are idealistic now but soon we’ll enter the “real world” and then realize that trying to make a difference is futile. That it’s pointless, and that we’ll succumb to cynicism instead. Then we’ll join the rest of society in getting a job just to advance, get promotions, and make tons of money.

Well, maybe it’s “cliche” to care or want to do something about the injustices around us. But the only way to take it beyond a cliche phase in a teenager’s life is to actually dedicate one’s career to this work, and never lose this idealism – even as you enter the ‘real world’ and have to face challenges such as buying a house, settling down with a family, or paying for your kids’ tuition. Only by making your passion your work can you show all the critics that making a difference isn’t a cliche, but that it’s actually a career, a life’s calling, and most of all – a possibility. It is possible to better the world, no matter how small. I’m not saying we can “save the world,” but we can contribute in a tiny way to improving the lives of others.

My best friend told me recently: “It’s only cliche when you’re young.” If you’re 40 and you stick to public interest work, you’re no longer going to be considered cliche – but instead, others will see you as someone with a meaningful career, impressive in your lifelong pursuit of social change and justice. You’ll be seen as a true advocate, not a teenager going through yet another “save the world” phase. Your 21-year old idealism doesn’t matter. What matters is whether you refuse to let it go.

  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

  1. Balancing idealism and realism
  2. Be the change: Challenging my Idealism, by Ruby Ku
  3. Being unique and following your passions
  4. Where are the Millennial public interest lawyers the world so desperately needs?
  5. Our generation: overeducated & underexperienced

  • Sarah Elizabeth

    I love this post, it hits home for me. My caring was always thought of as cliche also, and that once I started paying taxes I would “grow out of it.” Unfortunately life has not ended up with me working my dream job, but I have not succumb. At 29 years old, I will be quitting my current, good paying but mind numbing Wealth Management job and moving with my husband to Malaysia, with hopes of getting involved with an NGO and sex trafficking.

    I want to start all over again, and take another go at helping change the world for the better. I am sticking my tongue out at anyone who calls me cliche.. Those who have given up and decided to follow the mainstream are not my problem.

    [Reply]

  • http://akhilak.com/blog Akhila

    That's a big step to take and I'm so glad you're refusing to succumb to the critics and getting out there to do work you are passionate about. Best of luck with getting involved with an NGO ending sex trafficking – it's a very important issue, so I'm glad you're going for it! Best of luck with that :) I think it's hard to, at this point in life, continue to follow your dreams or work to better the world when everyone expects you to do something else/go for that nice suburban lifestyle. But I'm sure that taking the leap and the risk to make a difference will make you feel more fulfilled in the long run!

    [Reply]

  • Sarah Elizabeth

    Yea, I have always been more like the author of Eat Pray Love.. I don't want to do what is “expected” for me at my age, I will only be unhappy. Why not be nomadic while I am able and try to keep chasing my hopes and aspirations.. ?

    :)

    [Reply]

  • jrmoreau

    I always roll my eyes when my conservative family members tell me “if you're a liberal in your 20's, you're human, if you're liberal in your 30's, you're an idiot.” I always look at life as a zero sum game.. as in you're not coming out with more stuff than you came into it with. All you've really got is your memories and legacy. I don't want to be on my deathbed thinking back on an un-fulfilling, yet possession filled life.

    [Reply]

  • http://costaricaspanish.blogspot.com Thomas

    Great post! I understand the frustration of people viewing your life through the lens of their own narrow view of what life should be. What you need to be good at is distinguishing between the people who are cynical or jealous–and simply don't care whether you're successful in life–and the people who have skepticism that comes from a good, sincere place–and perhaps even a place of profound experience.

    I'm not going to say that idealism is ever a bad thing, but sometimes it can prevent people from reacting properly in a situation to create the best possible outcome.

    I recall one specific instance when a friend of mine was talking about this case study she had followed closely about women's political participation in Bangladesh. In this experiment, women were given training and financial support to start their own businesses. The hypothesis was that women, when given good businesses, would be afforded more economic influence AND would participate in local political affairs. As it turned out, the women did start, own, and operate successful businesses that 1) offered important services to the community, 2) gave women financial independence, and 3) allowed children to stay in school and hope for a better future than their parents'.

    Sounds like a pretty successful project, no? Well, my friend didn't think so. She could only complain that the businesses only helped the children of these women, and that the businesses kept them too busy to participate in local politics. It wasn't my initial reaction, but I could see her frustration. But then she totally floored me by suggesting that the businesses be taken away from the women so the project could be done over from scratch. Shocking.

    The ideal of women's political participation wasn't the problem. The problem was the single-mindedness that sprung from that ideal, making the virtues of other ideals nearly invisible to my friend.

    So, idealism isn't bad; letting your ideals make you stupid is. While law schools may be wrong in thinking that do-gooders are naive, you are committing an error of omission if you only talk about doing good in your entrance essay. I have written poor essays that go into idealistic soliloquies, and have had reasonable, skeptical (not cynical) people bring me down to earth and help me write something that demonstrates both idealism and understanding of the reality involved in pursuing ideals.

    [Reply]

  • Nathalie

    Great post! I think that in the end, what matters is that you choose a career that fulfills you and makes you happy. There are always people criticizing those who dare taking a different path, but it doesn't matter, it is your life not their.
    No corporate job, “prestige” or amount of money can provide you with happiness if it does not fit what you truly want to do with your life.

    [Reply]

  • http://akhilak.com/blog Akhila

    That's awesome, and I absolutely love that book. Obviously, we all have to do what we want in life rather than succumb to pressures put on us by society or other individuals, and only in that way can we be more fulfilled. I love the fact that Elizabeth Gilbert found happiness, contentment, and love by stepping away from these pressures. Sometimes getting out of the atmosphere of competitive and pressurizing American society can do wonders in helping us think outside the box and challenging us to see new things in life.

    [Reply]

  • http://akhilak.com/blog Akhila

    Oh, I absolutely hate that quote! I just don't understand why we're expected, almost REQUIRED, to become cynical and worn down. These types of quotes and statements from others force idealistic people into a small box, forcing them (or us) to thinking more narrowly as a whole. It cuts off the option that you can be idealistic, passionate, creative into your adulthood. Just because you're in your 30s doesn't mean you have to give up on your dreams, hopes, idealism, or desire to change the world. By sticking to these dreams and values we can all play a role in showing society that it IS possible.

    [Reply]

  • http://akhilak.com/blog Akhila

    It's absolutely true that no job or amount of prestige will make you happy unless it's something you truly want to do – but at the same time, some aren't happy doing work, even if it's something they love, if there isn't some level of societal prestige associated with it. Unfortunately, people are people and human beings will be human beings. We are primarily social creatures. That means that ultimately, we care deeply what other people think of us. We care about society even if we claim we don't. It's hard for people to completely throw away the idea of what society thinks of them. So, if you are pursuing your passion but are looked down upon for it, or aren't gaining respect from those you care about or admire, it's definitely difficult to ignore this aspect of it.

    [Reply]

  • http://akhilak.com/blog Akhila

    Very true – and I'm sorry it's taken me so long to respond to your comment! I am in agreement that idealism can blind you to some very important realities if you don't take the time to really look at things through a pragmatic lens. However, I think that your overall mindset can be idealistic while you make sure to take a pragmatic approach. Never lose sight of what you ultimately want to achieve and the big goals you want to accomplish – bu be sure to work towards them while acknowledging the current reality of things.

    I think there's definitely a difference between this and skepticism though. We do need a healthy dose of skepticism, but there is definitely the possibility of going too far. We don't want to become so pessimistic and skeptical that we blind ourselves to the possibility of doing good and making a change. We don't want to become so cynical as to doubt that any positive change can actually happen.

    [Reply]

blog comments powered by Disqus